But Gould was probably best known as a populiser of science who wrote hundreds of short essays on science that were characterised by their accessbility. Gould was able to discuss quite complex scientific ideas, often beginning with a literary or sporting anecdote that would illustrate his wider point. Many of these essays have been collected in books such as Bully for Brontosaurus which remain very popular.
An Urchin in the Storm is one of those collections, but it is unusual as it is a selection of Gould's book reviews. Which means that this blog is me reviewing a book of book reviews. It is likely that few readers of this book will have read more than one or two of the books that Gould is covering, as most of them are scientific works. I, for instance, have only read Not in Our Genes by Steven Rose, R. C. Lewontin and Leon Kamin, and that was thirty years ago. Not in Our Genes is a great polemic against biological determinism and one that celebrates "dialectical thinking". Characteristically in his positive review of this, Gould opens with an anecdote from his travels studying snails and finishes with Karl Marx's final thesis on Feuerbach.
There is not a dull essay/review in this book. But some of them stand out. Four of them are biographies, and one of these is of the Black American scientist E.E. Just whose work on fertilisation was unknown to me, and whose academic and personal life was marred by racism. Just travelled to Europe were he was able to work in less oppressive situation, but arriving there in the 1930s Gould says that Just "demonstrated an almost incredible naiveté, blinded no doubt by the understandable joy he felt for his new life... towards the growth of fascism in Germany and Italy". Just wasn't a great fighter for civil liberates and against oppression. In fact Gould reports "more than a small streak of anti-Semitism". But Gould also notes that Just's story, which meant that he was never able to achieve his potential because of racism, "underscores the most important question of all: how can we secure these benefits for everybody?"
Another quite famous article collected here is Gould highly critical review of Jeremy Rifkin's book Algeny. It is a good example of the idea that some of the best reviews are negative. Gould says taht Algeny is "a cleverly constructed tract of anti-intellectual propaganda masquerading as scholarship. Among books promoted as serious intellectual statements by important thinkers, I don't think I have ever read a shoddier work". It is a damning comment and not one that most authors would be able to recover from. It did not stop Rifkin however.
The critical review of Rifkin's book is important however not for Gould's exposes of Rifkin's mistakes, but for how he uses the review as a jumping off point to example evolutionary concepts and leaves the reader feeling that they know more about a subject then they did, without needing to stoop to read the object of Gould's wrath. Gould concludes:
I have been so harsh beause I believe that Rifkin has seriously harmed a cause that is very dear to me and to nearly all my scientific colleagues. Rifkin has placed all of us beyond the pale of deceny by arguing that scientific paradigms are simple expressions of socioeconomic bias, that biotech implies... a new view of organisms as strings of separable infromation (not wholes of necessary integrity) and that all scientists will eventually go along with this heartless idea.
Some of the articles cover subjects that are even more contested than when Gould wrote the articles in the 1990s. One book he reviews is Anne Fausto-Sterling's Myths of Gender, which contests studies that try to demonstrate differences between genders in society are the result of genetics. It is a "courageous" book says Gould, which celebrates "null results" - the idea that you can take seriously results that don't show expected (or any) answers. Gould:
For example, poorer spatial perception is frequently cited as a different cognitive style for women. Fausto-Sterling shows that such differences occur insocieties that greatly restrict the autonomy and physical movement of girls during early upbringin, but have not been detected in cultures (including Eskimos) that grant equal freedom to boys and girls.
One review I really liked covers a book by Loren Eiseley that argues Charles Darwin "made use" of the work of the "gifted natural historian" Edward Blyth, who it was claimed "developed a version of natural selection before Darwin". What's remarkable here is that Gould, in turn, refutes Eiseley's book through his own deep knowledge of Darwin's work, Blyth's work and the scientific process that Darwin went though. Not least Gould's awareness that the word "inosculate" was a common technical term in the "hot subject" of "quinarian system". This sounds obscure, but its deployment by Gould feels like a Colombo "one last thing" moment.
Gould's essays are always a joy to read. But as a whole the collection comes across as a defence of the idea that you cannot reduce individuals down to their biology. Instead, we need to take their circumstances, their history, their context into account to fully understand them. It is a conclusion that remains and important starting point for scientific debate today. But one that remains frighteningly contested.
For those who love science and the scientific method, particular as practised by a scientist whose politicals were on the left, these book reviews open up arguments and debates that you never knew existed, but become utterly embroiled in. They are also celebrations of literature and culture. You'll love them even if you aren't a biologist. They remind us that the best scientists are ones that look beyond the science.
Related Reviews
Gould - Wonderful Life: The Burgess Shale and the Nature of History
Desmond & Moore - Darwin's Sacred Cause






