Monday, November 16, 2026

Stephen Jay Gould - An Urchin in the Storm

Stephen Jay Gould was a palentologist, evolutionary biologist and prolific writer. His scientific work included the evolutionary concept of puctuated equilibrium which he developed Niles Eldredge. A theory that argues that evolution is not a gradual process, but one characterised by long periods of little or no change, followed by periods of great change. 

But Gould was probably best known as a populiser of science who wrote hundreds of short essays on science that were characterised by their accessbility. Gould was able to discuss quite complex scientific ideas, often beginning with a literary or sporting anecdote that would illustrate his wider point. Many of these essays have been collected in books such as Bully for Brontosaurus which remain very popular.

An Urchin in the Storm is one of those collections, but it is unusual as it is a selection of Gould's book reviews. Which means that this blog is me reviewing a book of book reviews. It is likely that few readers of this book will have read more than one or two of the books that Gould is covering, as most of them are scientific works. I, for instance, have only read Not in Our Genes by Steven Rose, R. C. Lewontin and Leon Kamin, and that was thirty years ago. Not in Our Genes is a great polemic against biological determinism and one that celebrates "dialectical thinking". Characteristically in his positive review of this, Gould opens with an anecdote from his travels studying snails and finishes with Karl Marx's final thesis on Feuerbach.

There is not a dull essay/review in this book. But some of them stand out. Four of them are biographies, and one of these is of the Black American scientist E.E. Just whose work on fertilisation was unknown to me, and whose academic and personal life was marred by racism. Just travelled to Europe were he was able to work in less oppressive situation, but arriving there in the 1930s Gould says that Just "demonstrated an almost incredible naiveté, blinded no doubt by the understandable joy he felt for his new life... towards the growth of fascism in Germany and Italy".  Just wasn't a great fighter for civil liberates and against oppression. In fact Gould reports "more than a small streak of anti-Semitism". But Gould also notes that Just's story, which meant that he was never able to achieve his potential because of racism, "underscores the most important question of all: how can we secure these benefits for everybody?"

Another quite famous article collected here is Gould highly critical review of Jeremy Rifkin's book Algeny. It is a good example of the idea that some of the best reviews are negative. Gould says taht Algeny is "a cleverly constructed tract of anti-intellectual propaganda masquerading as scholarship. Among books promoted as serious intellectual statements by important thinkers, I don't think I have ever read a shoddier work". It is a damning comment and not one that most authors would be able to recover from. It did not stop Rifkin however. 

The critical review of Rifkin's book is important however not for Gould's exposes of Rifkin's mistakes, but for how he uses the review as a jumping off point to example evolutionary concepts and leaves the reader feeling that they know more about a subject then they did, without needing to stoop to read the object of Gould's wrath. Gould concludes:

I have been so harsh beause I believe that Rifkin has seriously harmed a cause that is very dear to me and to nearly all my scientific colleagues. Rifkin has placed all of us beyond the pale of deceny by arguing that scientific paradigms are simple expressions of socioeconomic bias, that biotech implies... a new view of organisms as strings of separable infromation (not wholes of necessary integrity) and that all scientists will eventually go along with this heartless idea.

Some of the articles cover subjects that are even more contested than when Gould wrote the articles in the 1990s. One book he reviews is Anne Fausto-Sterling's Myths of Gender, which contests studies that try to demonstrate differences between genders in society are the result of genetics. It is a "courageous" book says Gould, which celebrates "null results" - the idea that you can take seriously results that don't show expected (or any) answers. Gould:

For example, poorer spatial perception is frequently cited as a different cognitive style for women. Fausto-Sterling shows that such differences occur insocieties that greatly restrict the autonomy and physical movement of girls during early upbringin, but have not been detected in cultures (including Eskimos) that grant equal freedom to boys and girls.

One review I really liked covers a book by Loren Eiseley that argues Charles Darwin "made use" of the work of the "gifted natural historian" Edward Blyth, who it was claimed "developed a version of natural selection before Darwin". What's remarkable here is that Gould, in turn, refutes Eiseley's book through his own deep knowledge of Darwin's work, Blyth's work and the scientific process that Darwin went though. Not least Gould's awareness that the word "inosculate" was a common technical term in the "hot subject" of "quinarian system". This sounds obscure, but its deployment by Gould feels like a Colombo "one last thing" moment.

Gould's essays are always a joy to read. But as a whole the collection comes across as a defence of the idea that you cannot reduce individuals down to their biology. Instead, we need to take their circumstances, their history, their context into account to fully understand them. It is a conclusion that remains and important starting point for scientific debate today. But one that remains frighteningly contested. 

For those who love science and the scientific method, particular as practised by a scientist whose politicals were on the left, these book reviews open up arguments and debates that you never knew existed, but become utterly embroiled in. They are also celebrations of literature and culture. You'll love them even if you aren't a biologist. They remind us that the best scientists are ones that look beyond the science.

Related Reviews

Gould - Wonderful Life: The Burgess Shale and the Nature of History
Desmond & Moore - Darwin's Sacred Cause

Sunday, November 15, 2026

Sarah Bates, Judy Cox & Sally Campbell - Breaking Our Chains: Women, Marxism and the Path to Liberation

Around the world the far-right are pushing a misogynist agenda and trying to roll back and attack women's rights. Ironically they are often doing this while claiming to defend women. But their vision of the role of women in society is a remarkably backward one. Their vision is that women work in the home, rearing children and doing domestic duties.

I start this review with these points because they form a central point of this important book on women's liberation. But also because the far-right's vision of the role of women is an extension of the way that women are oppressed under capitalism. In particular, the role of the "capitalist family" means that the oppression of women is closely linked to the dynamics of capitalist exploitation. Understanding the way that women are oppressed, the book argues, means understanding the structures and history of capitalism. As the authors say:

The capitalist family is nearly impossible to escape. Attempts to build collective, experimental, or radical alternatives have remained small-scale and short-lived.... the private family is a relatively recent creation of class society - barely 10,000 years old. Its currently capitalist form, the nuclear family, is presented as natural and eternal. But it didn't emerge by chance; it is a product of class domination and the system's need for profit, shaped by the needs of industrial society.

Breaking Our Chains draws on the work of Marx and Engels. It defends this approach from feminist and leftist traditions critical of Marxism, arguing that the approach of Marx and Engels means we can understand the rise of the family and women's oppression in the context of the history of class society, class society and the specific needs of capitalism. This is not to say that the authors merely talk about how Marx and Engels wrote. One of the great strengths of the book is how it discusses the way oppression has changed through time. For instance there is a really useful section on "Misogyny and the manosphere" that examines how online misogyny is linked to developments in capitalism, both in terms of technology but also the way that women's lives have changed and how the right respond. The writers say:

The manosphere is also shaped by the way women's lives have changed. Women today face the pressure of expectations to have both a family and a successful career. Women's visiblity in employent and public life is used to justify one of the central claims of figures like Andrew Tate - that feminism has gone 'too far' and women now have the dominant role in society. FEminism, the yassert, is causing a crisis of masculinity.

The conclusion has to be to challenge these ideas, but it is not enough to educate boys and young men, what is needed is "the act of fighting together and the xperience of living alongside each other [which] often forces people to confront the contradictions between te ideas they find online and the relationships they have with those around them.

In part this is a problem for the right. Their desire to attack abortion rights, for instance, is a weak link for the right because millions of women understand that abortion rights are something they need. The book quotes useful figures about how abortion rights are supported across (for instance) the US political spectrum, undermining Trump's claim to defend women.

Two other important sections of this book should be highlighted. The first is the section on transgender. Here the authors show how a materialist approach to biology, which places human biology within wider social contexts, undermines the crude biological reductionism of many "Gender Critical Feminists": "Our bodies do not exist outside history and society. They are shaped by imperialism, by gender, and by class". They continue:

How we understand our bodies and interpret our gender is both deeply personal and influenced by wider social forces. Marx argued that there is no such thing as a fixed 'natural' state for humanity. The concept of what is 'natural' changes over time - as we labour on nature to satisfy our needs, we change nature and we change ourselves.

The second section that I want to highlight is the critical engagement the authors make with "challenges to Marxism". In particular I found the section on Social Reproduction Theory very interesting, because the authors point out the limits of SRT that while it begins from the limits of capitalism's approach to things like women's labour in the home, it wrongly places social reproduction as the drive for capital accumulation. The authors argue this is wrong, because it is the quest for profits that drives the system and this has "produced a dynamic system that constatnly exerts pressure on existing socail relationships and ultiamtely fuels changes in the family". The key thing, they emphasise, is that "production and reprouction are part of a unitary system, but production plays the ddominant role in generating social change".

This is a short book of just 130 pages, but it contains within it a breadth of material and a depth of understanding that I genuinely was impressed with. It serves as an excellent primer on Marxism and Women's Oppression and is thoroughly up to date with the latest arguements from both the feminist and right-wing. But it also constantly points out that there is a powerful tradition of struggle from below that has both won women further rights, but also pointed the way forward to revolution which can produce structural change. The final chapter deals with the gains of the Russian Revolution and demonstrates the potential for how we can all win true liberation. Well worth a read.

Related Reviews

Orr - Sexism and the System, A Rebel's Guide to Women's Liberation
Orr - Marxism and Women's Liberation
Rowbotham - Hidden from History
Leacock - Myths of Male Dominance
Engels - Origins of the Family, Private Property and the State
Miles - Transgender Resistance: Socialism and the fight for trans liberation

Saturday, November 14, 2026

Nigel Saul - Richard II

Richard II is probably most famous for two things: his central role in the Peasants' Revolt of 1381, which saw him see off a mass rebellion of England's most discontented people and Shakespeare's play about his downfall in the face of Henry IV, a childhood friend who fell victim to Richard's powerplays.

Nigel Saul's biography of Richard II opens with Shakespeare who, interestingly enough, doesn't make 1381 part of his play, dwelling instead on the "King and Man" who seemingly brought disaster upon himself. But after a quick opening chapter on Shakespeare, Saul quickly moves into a more orthodox history of the man. Richard II had a strong pedigree. His father was the military genius and violent feudal knight, Edward the Black Prince. His mother the indomitable Joan, Countess of Kent. His grandfather was Edward III which matters particularly because it meant that when the Black Prince died young, and his grandfather Edward followed a year later, Richard became King at just ten years of age.

Feudal courts were nothing if not a site of intrigue and alliance building. Richard's youth meant he was a pawn in wider power games, and this shaped his later life. Saul argues that while Richard managed to break free of the forces using him, he increasingly found himself creating a centralised state around himself. But this is to get slightly ahead of ourselves.

When the Peasants' Revolt broke out in 1381 Richard was fourteen, and on the cusp of adulthood by Medieval standards. His leading role in the defeat of that uprising has been much discussed. Richard is occasionally, not least in the recent Paul Greengrass film The Uprising, painted as sympathetic toward the rebels. Indeed one of my reasons for reading this book was to see if there was any material that would shed light on this. Saul says firmly the opposite. He writes, "Certinaly it is unlikely that Richard felt any mustical sympathy for the rebels: all his adult life he was to lay emphasis on the subject's obligation of obedience". But Saul continues to point out that after the rebellion Richard clearly felt obliged to play a role in the manumission of the rebels. Nevertheless Richad's own words, "with his own mouth", in Saul's words "show himself unsympathetic", encouraging repression of rebels following the uprising. 

Much later in his life, Saul argues that Richard remained (or was increasingly) unsympathetic to those beneath him in the feudal hierarchy. Saul writes:
There is no reason to suppose that Richard was greatly concerned by his subjects; attitude, favourable or otherwise, towards him. Such evidence as there is suggests that he was disdainful of the opinions of others. He made little attempt to seek his subjects' goodwhile and affection, and he showed himse indifferent to their aspirations. As he became more powerful in the 1390s, so he became more aloof, and possible also more arrogant.
Saul draws on one contemporary chronicle that depicts Richard's growing arrogance.
As the Eulogium writes narrates, it became [Richard's] practice to sit enthroned fomr dinner till vespers, observed by his courtiers, who were expected to bend the knee whenever his gaze fell on them. At the same time the chroniclers tell how he was increasingly given to spekding his time in the company of sycophants and cronies.
Of course such behaviours are hardly unique among monarchs. In our own times we have heard accounts of the behaviour of recent Princes and Kings who have demanded similar obsequience. In addition after Richard's fall there was a need to portray him in a negative light and these allegations certainly helped legitmise his replacement.

Nonetheless it is clear that Richard's behaviour at court, his increasingly dismissal of anyone but a few loyal sycophants and his stripping of enemies of wealth and titles undermined his own rule dramatically. His end was pathetic and depressing, and probably unlike Shakespeare's portrayal. 

Saul concludes that Ricahrd was, however, engaged in a process of developing the feudal state into a more national and centralised structure. He sees an "overall similarity between his kingly style and that of his fellow rulers in Europe. In many European states at this time prices were seeking to 'distance' themselves from their subjects. The stimulus to their action was provided by the growing prosperity of the lower orders... rulers needed to reassert their pre-eminence by exalting or 'distincing' themselves." 

Further, and not unconvincingly, Saul suggests that this instinct meshed with Richard's own temperament, finding evidence as far back as Richard's lonely childhood. 

As with any biography it is often difficult to separate the work from the subject. Nonetheless a few words ought to be said about the book itself. Despite this being the classic biography from the renowned Yale English Monarch series I was disappointed. Saul offers very little context on the lives and livelihoods of those subjects that Richard ruled. Even though Richad oversaw the repression of the greatest pre-modern rebellion in European history, there's precious little here about why the rebellion occured. Saul prefers to dwell (and he is an expert on) the material about Richard's life and person. It makes for a frustrating and dry read. I also felt that the book felt more older than its 1997 publication date would suggest. In discussing the lack of children between Richard and his beloved first Queen Anne, Saul writes that "the most likely explanation for the couple's childlessness is that either she was barren or he was infertile". The language here feels unfortunately dated. 

While this is a useful historical overview of Richard II's life, it felt more like a textbook. I will keep it for reference, but I doubt it will excite a re-read.

Related Reviews

Friday, November 06, 2026

Roger Moorhouse - Wolfpack: Inside Hitler’s U-Boat War

On the 19th September 1943, Erich Janowitz, my Great Uncle on my mother's side, died in U-341, a German submarine operating south-west of Iceland. It was the boat and Erich Janowitz's second voyage. He was 21. 

Reading Roger Moorhouse's new book was, in part, an attempt by me to find out more about Erich's life in the service of Germany's war machine. There are many books that have looked at the Battle of the Atlantic, but few of them have considered the war from the German perspective and tried to understand how the German submarine crews lived, fought and died. That's not to say that the German U-boat experience has been ignored. The 1981 German film Das Boot famously depicted the horrors of submarine war, based as it was on the 1973 book by Lothar-Günther Buchheim, a German journalist who had travelled with U-96 on one patrol in the Atlantic. Moorhouse explains that Buchheim's photographic account of this voyage was almost completely destroyed in a bombing raid. But the author turned his experiences into a book and film.

Moorhouse's account turns a lot of what I thought I knew about the submarine war on its head. He argues, convincingly, that the submarine war was a lot more one-sided than is usually thought. In the first few years Admiral Dönitz led a vastly inadequate force, but a force that was led by experienced and trained commanders. In this era, before the convoy system was fully implemented and before the Allies developed new technologies properly, the U-boat was highly effective. The victories of a few highly successful commander was a propaganda godsend to the Nazi regime, and led to a plethora of recruits. But the square jawed heroic image of the submarine commander was very different to reality.

Picture the scene. A U-boat returns from patrol at one of the ports in the Bay of Biscay that the German's captured after the fall of France. The hatch opens and the dockworkers move to help. They stop, recoiling from the stink. The so called "U-boat stench" after a long patrol was appalling. Grizzled, pale, sick men get out. Trips on U-boats, contemporary doctors reported, were awful. Men were covered in boils and rashes and infected with STDs. Their accommodation was full of cockroaches and bugs. Food was rotten, unhealthy and covered in mould. If the crews lived till the end of their patrol, then they had done so in conditions that ought to have provoked mutiny.

Making it to the end of the patrol, never mind the end of the war, was for German submariners unlikely. Of the 41,000 who went to war on submarines, only 11,000 survived. A death rate that Moorhouse says "unmatched" in any other theatre of WW2. Not only this, but as the war progressed, anti-submarine warfare developed and Germany went from being on the offensive to being pressed on all sides, losses mounted. Moorhouse says that "more than a third of U-boats lost during the war, were lost on their maiden patrol". Crews from 1943 onward were inexperienced, badly trained and ill-equipped. Losses were colossal. At one point Moorhouse tells the account of the burial at sea of a sailor killed in an air attack. The story is unusual, because such burials were unusual. Most of the dead were part of a "total loss" of their craft. Of 859 U-boats that went into combat 429 had "no survivors and no bodies". 95 percent of those killed had "no grave but the sea".

By May of 1943 Dönitz had to admit defeat in the Battle of the Atlantic. It was a few months before my Great Uncle was killed there. Even the retreat from that front-line did not mean that losses were improved. 

What of the successes for the German U-boats. The attacks on convoys to Britain loom large in popular accounts of the war. There is, no doubt, a case to be made that U-boat attacks severely hampered Britain's ability to fight Germany, particularly in the first years of the war. Famously, and much quoted by Moorhouse, Churchill said that the "only thing that ever really frightened him" was the "U-boat peril". Some of the early successes were astounding. But the sinking of ships was concentrated in a very small number of ships - while most crews sank no ships at all. The totals seem large. U-boats sank almost 3,500 ships in the war, over 15 million tonnes. But the merchant fleets of the Western Allies and the British Empire never fell below 14 million tonnes and even in 1939 Britain had access to 18 million tonnes of merchant shipping. Later in the war, when Liberty ships were being built almost by the day, there was no real shortage. 

Had Dönitz's pre-war ambitions of a 300 strong U-boat fleet been realised, then he may well have brought Britain to its knees. But the Nazi regime's belief in the U-boat came too late and was badly neglected by Hitler's obsessions with attacking the Soviet Union. 

One important discussion that Moorhouse leads is whether the German submarine service was different to the rest of the German military. Despite well-documented atrocities, such as the sinking of civilian and POW ships, there are remarkably few atrocities committed by submariners during WW2. Perhaps, Moorhouse points out, there were many more but the crews that committed them were lost. Or perhaps there is some truth in the argument that the insular nature of submarines, their isolation from the Nazi machinery and bureaucracy also insulated them from the worst of the regime. Moorhouse also suggests that the officers themselves tended to come from a professional class that was hostile, or rather less than enthusiastic about the Nazis. Despite some cases of anti-Hitler politics and actions that Moorhouse tells us (some of which are breathtakingly brave) I am sceptical that there was any sort of systematic anti-Nazi feeling. I think was more likely a general antipathy to murdering fellow sailors.

That said, I came away feeling that Dönitz was far more of a war-criminal than I had previously considered. I felt the book's conclusions was a little softer on him than I'd thought. While some senior Allied naval figures clearly felt he had been done an injustice, Moorhouse's material (even if not his conclusions) suggest much darker conclusions.

Moorhouse's book puts a lot of evidence forward that suggests that the U-boat war waged by Germany was a material negative for the regime. It was a vast drain in terms of material and people, research and development and money. Certainly by the second half of WW2 the Allies ability to read secret German codes gave them an advantage that could not be defeated. The failure of a third of U-boats to survive their first voyage and sink next to no enemy vessels demonstrates this. That said the U-boat threat also diverted a lot of material for the Allies and the propaganda threat must have been high for Germany. Ultimately though it is not hard to think that this was a horrific aspect to a horrific war that could have been avoided.

Moorhouse finishes his book by describing a visit to the U-boat memorial at Heikendorf, near Kiel. Tragically my Great-Grandmother never learnt that her son was memorialised there. Erich Janowitz's name is on a bronze plaque with the names of those who died alongside him in U-341. 30,000 other names cover hundreds of other plaques. A few hundred miles away across the North Sea, the names of tens of thousands of British victims of U-boat attacks on merchant shipping are recorded on a remarkably similar memorial on Tower Hill in London. Many more names are forgotten.

The combat life of those who served in U-boats was uncomfortable, dangerous and frequently short. Roger Moorhouse's account of the German experience never sanitises it, or turns it into heroism. It was just a small, dirty, part of a horrific, genocidal, war. 

Related Reviews

Woodman - The Real Cruel Sea: The Merchant Navy in the Battle of the Atlantic 1939-1943
Lund & Harry Ludlam - PQ17: Convoy to Hell
Monsarrat - Three Corvettes

Tuesday, November 03, 2026

Karl Marx - Capital Volume II

In his preface to the Penguin edition of the second volume of Karl Marx's Capital, the translator David Fernbach notes, with palpable frustration that it is a difficult book to read. Those readers who have finished the first volume will know that one of the great triumphs of that book is that it is a work of political economy, and literature. It is full of references to history, legend and culture and rages, in places, with anger at the conditions in which the proletariat live and work. Capital II, Fernbach says, is not like this, it is "remowned for the arid deserts between its oases". Many a "non-specialist" says Fernbach has been defeated.

I don't disagree with Fernbach at all here. Capital II is undoubtably a work of great intellectual power and weight. There is no doubt that had Marx finished it, it would have been imbibed with purple passages, allusions and the reader would have been eased through the technical parts much more. It also, no doubt, suffers from its origins in the collection of notebooks that Engels edited after Marx death. But for this reader it must be said it was a very challenging read.

The book is clearly intended as a direct follow on from Volume I. Marx references that earlier work frequently, and the reader is assumed to be familiar with the topic. But this is a much more focused work, dealing with the circulation of capital within capitalism in a variety of different contexts and situations. Key to this analysis is how, and when, the value of commodities can be realised. Marx then discusses various scenarios of what the capitalists are able to do with this value, and how they can reinvest in different parts of production in order to continue their search for profit.

While Marx never loses sight of the role of workers ("the first precondition of M-C... P... C'-M' is the continuous availability of the ckass of wage-labourers") this is not the primary, or even secondary focus of the book. Marx is more concerned with drawing out the real nature of production, and he criticises the classical economists for obscuring, or not seeing, the drive for profit and accumulation. Take this section:

The general form of the movement P ... P is the form of reproduction and, unlike M ... M', does not indicate that valorisation is the prupose of the process. For this reason, classical economics found it all the more easy to ignore the specifically capitalist form of the production process, and to present production as such as the purpose of the porcess - to produce as much and as cheaply as possible and to exchange the production for as many other products as possible, partly for th ereptition of production (M-C), partly for consumption (m-c). 

The whole process then appearing simple and natural, i.e. possessing the naturalness of superficial rationality... Accumulation, of course, appeared in the same light as production.

Classical economics presents "production" as the purpose, not the making of profits. Here Marx uses the notation M... M' to refer to the circuit of Money-Capital, P... P' for the circuit of Productive-Capital and C...C' for the circut of Commodity-Capital. 

In noting the circulation of capital, Marx has to take up some interesting questions. For instance time becomes a factor. How does capitalism work when capital is locked up on productions on ships on the sea, or waiting for beer to brew or crops to grow. Marx emphasises that "the nearer production time and working time approach to eqaulity, the greater the productivity and valorisation of a given productive capital in a given space of time". He continues that the tendency is for the system to "shorten as much as possible the excess of production time over working time".

Examples such as these exist in the book, but as the work progresses it becomes harder and much more abstract. The pages are peppered with equations and calculations, and few readers will be able to follow the detail of Marx's arguement. This is further complicated by Engels' admission that while Marx had a "firm grasp of algebra, he was never at ease in recokoning with figures" and "in his turnover calculations Marx became confused". Thus Engels only includes the "correct calculations". He also points to further problems because he argues Marx gives too much significance to something Engels considers of "little importance", the "setting-free of money capital". This reader is happy to let Engels have the last word here.

Capital II is a difficult read. Readers will, especially if familiar with the first volume, get something from it. I found Marx's writing on natural processes, such as crops and trees growing, to the production system illuminating. But I was much defeated by the later passages. Though even there I found the occasional gem. While there were few oases I did, at least occasionally, drink.

Related Reviews

Marx - Capital Volume I
Marx - Value, Price and Profit
Marx - The Civil War in France
Marx - Grundrisse

Sunday, November 01, 2026

A.K. Blakemore - Doom Painting

The release of Paul Greengrass' film The Uprising about the events of the 1381 English Peasants' Revolt have spurred me to read, or reread a number of works that I last read when writing "Kill all the Gentlemen". Perhaps the greatest pleasure however has been reading A.K. Blakemore's new novel Doom Painting which tells the story of the rising through the experiences of a number of key figures, particularly Wat Tyler.

Doom Painting begins where almost all accounts of 1381 should begin, with the poll tax collection in Fobbing, Essex. Even in the archival accounts its a violent event, laden with centuries of oppression and exploitation. But the archives don't give you a sense of the culmultative resentment and frustration of ordinary people. Blakemore however gives it us in spades, "A gasp, as an afternoon is confounded: Thomas Baker spits a lug of phlegm at the pointed toes of Sir John de Bampton's cherry-red poulaines."

Baker, she continues "has become familiar" with the "skinned-palm feeling of humiliation" of oppression. He and the others in Fobbing, "are sick of the tax collectors and assessors and serjeants-at-arms, who come at every change of the season, with the teetering and vauely comical officiousness of earthbound magpecks".

Even this cursory quote will give the reader a sense of aspects that are clearly very important to Blakemore's novel. The first is the palpable revulsion at injustice that runs through her book. The second is her frequent references to the smells, tastes, dirt and bodily fluids of feudal England. This is a world of oozing mud, dirty clothing, lice, smells and lack of privacy and disease. It's also a world of sex and violence. Wat Tyler, when he appears (and he surely does appear in this telling), is born of a world of violence, pillage and, tragically, rape. A veteran of what is now known as the Hundred Years War, he's seen his share of collective punishment, war and siege. He knows, for instance, that taking Rochester Castle will be impossible for a peasant army, unless something tips the balance.

And what does tip the balance? Here, and elsewhere? It is the, of course, the masses. In many ways it is Blakemore's ability to give the reader a sense of what the movement on the ground was like that makes this is truely unique work. All too often in novels that deal with mass movements readers are offered a mass of people that are somehow perfigured. Everyone seems to know what they are fighting for, and what they stand for. The leaders are ready cut men (usually men) who are fighitng for an ideal. It's a crude caricature of a movement and Doom Painting doesn't fall into the trap. Instead Tyler is a man whose sense of what is needed develops. Unlike John Ball, the poet and conscience of the rebellion, he has no thought out ideas. Just a grim hatred of injustice and liking of violence. As the rebellion unfolds, Tyler develops a real sense of the potential of the rising, and his own place in it. 

In fact there's a remarkable speech that Blakemore puts into Tyler's mouth. It's not one that begins, as polished political rhetoric inevitably does, with lofty ideals and promises of victory. It's one that begins with the reality of war and the cruelty of life, and the promise that everyone will stand by each other and that Tyler will do his best for them. Nothing more, nothing less. The later chants of the crowd, when Tyler's better known and his feats have grown in the telling, are even more earthy, but carry the ring of the working-class movement confident in itself and its leaders, "his name's Wat the Tyler and he shits where he likes".

I presume that Blakemore has her own experience of the joyous nature of protesting crowds. Because the book's depiction of the growing rebellion as it marches on London and executes its enemies, feels true. No one comes into the is rebellion perfect, and certainly no one is made perfect by the movement. After all, the "tradition of all dead generations weighs like a nightmare on the brains of the living" and we carry with us the muck of ages. But the people are changed - in confidence and vision, and Blakemore shows us how.

At the other end of the scale is the venel, cowardly, violent and lazy ruling class. "But I am King of England" complains Richard II at one point. They are secure in their class strata and castles, confident that nothing can threaten them, protected by their armed bodies of men. Certainly this reader enjoyed reading of the collapse of their self-belief (and the occasional castle) and the rising panic in their ranks. One thing that I think Blakemore shows us well though, is that what distinguishes the rich and powerful from the ordinary masses is not just wealth. It is also the luxury of leisure. The rich and powerful waste time with gossip and intrigue, games and leisure. The poor, when they aren't sharpening swords and marching on the capital, work dawn to dusk and drink to forget. Which means their lives are ones of misery and desperation.

Doom Painting is a remarkable work. It's a retelling of a well known story that doesn't offer the reader a pretend, Hollywood, happy ending like The Uprising does. Nor does it pretend that its heroes are saints. Running through it is a celebration of the potential of ordinary people to change the world, and an instinctive solidarity with those who try. This is 1381 brought to life. 

Related Reviews

Oman - The Great Revolt of 1381
Firnhaber-Baker & Schoenaers - The Routledge History Handbook of Medieval Revolt
Dunn - The Peasants' Revolt: England's failed revolution of 1381
Lindsay & Groves - The Peasants' Revolt 1381
Hilton - Bond Men Made Free: Medieval Peasant Movements and the English Rising of 1381
Barker - England Arise! The People, the King & the Great Revolt of 1381

Thursday, October 29, 2026

Michael Löwy & Olivier Besancenot - Marx in Paris

As all socialist eyes turn to the current rebellion in France it is instructive to look at historic examples of French revolution. The greatest of all of these, from a Marxist point of view, was the Paris Commune. The 1871 workers' revolution that saw the city taken over by it's working population and run, albeit briefly, un a radical democratic way. One of Karl Marx's greatest writings is his Civil War in France. His trenchant defence of the Communards and how he articulated the lessons he had learnt from the Commune.

Marx never saw the Commune in real life. He learnt what he knew from its documents and its refugees, and the active participation of members of the International Workingmens Association. But this short volume imagines that Marx, led by his daughter Jenny, did visit Paris in 1871 in disguise, at the height of its struggles. The novel, written by to great socialist activists, Michael Löwy and Olivier Besancenot, imagines how Karl and Jenny Marx were inspired to travel by the news of workers' revolution, and their impressions. The book is supposed to be a forgotten notebook by Jenny, hidden for fear of alerting the authorities to Marx's visit to Paris and further threatening activists there.

On arrival in France, the authors have Karl and Jenny visit great revolutionaries, all of them working every hour possible to organise the Commune and to implement socialist ideas. Their conversations draw out both the achievements of the revolution both in terms of its transformative policies and the mass participation. In particular they visit Elisabeth Dmitrieff, a member of the IWA who founded the Women's Union to Defend Paris and Care for the Wounded. This organisation was much more than a medical organisation. It was an activist body that fought to demand the participation and equal rights for women in the Commune. They also meet with  Louise Michel, a more famous participant, who placed herself on the front-lines militarily and politically.

The are some fascinating moments in this little piece of alternative history, and I did like the moments when Karl showed Jenny the places he knew from his own history and sites of historic organisation. But I found the book marred by its clunky prose. Too many of the conversations between Karl Marx and Communards felt like quotes from Marx's books and articles. The discussions felt stilted and unauthentic, rather like two conversationalists reading out polemics at each other. 

Jenny's own thoughts are better constructed and her excitment at the participation of women and her reacquaintance with friends is well depicted.

The authors have done well to draw out the main arguments (Karl repeatedly suggests that the Communards should appropriate the central bank and march on Versailles). But these pieces of politics cannot rescue the novel itself.

Related Reviews

Lissagaray - History of the Paris Commune
Abidor - Voices of the Paris Commune
Marx - The Civil War in France
Merriman - Massacre: The Life & Death of the Paris Commune of 1871
Gluckstein - The Paris Commune - A Revolution in Democracy