Had I been asked a month ago whether a book dominated (ha)
by sadomasochistic sex scenes, whose convoluted plot involves ritual murder,
the lofty realms of academic philosophy and a smattering of anthropology,
London in-jokes and Neanderthals could be a runaway success I would have laugh
out loud.
Given the runaway success of Fifty Shades of Grey
though, I would no longer be sure of my instant dismissal. In fact, I would
argue that whoever could leap aboard that particular bandwagon would be in with
a good chance of making their fortune.
It is just possible, just, that Ann Abrams might make it.
Given that Fifty Shades was in itself a sexed up piece of Twilight
fan-fiction, I am sure that there will be a plethora of authors and publishers
eager to follow E. L. James success. No doubt they'll all have similar
inoffensive covers, shades of blue and grey fooling no-one on the bus.
Mobius
however deserves better than being seen as some publishers wet-dream of a quick
trip to the fortunes of Harry Potter. Certainly Abrams herself is more than J K
Rowling, not least with her in-jokes and ruminations on the ideas of Hegel,
Marx and half a dozen philosophers. You get the impression that Abrams has
actually read these, rather than flicking through a cartoon-guide to Rousseau.
There's also humour. Dark humour, but bits that'll make you smile.
Abrams clearly lives in London. Or at least she knows it
well enough to understand the frustrations of most Londoners towards the influx
of middle-class attic dwelling hipsters that is spreading outwards from
Shoreditch and trying to setup abode in Dalston. Abrams' turns our annoyance at
their superficiality into satisfaction with the occasional (well frequent) act
of violence. The satisfaction is swiftly followed by horror of course, but
knowing that those we dislike meet a grisly end is possibly were some of the
success of this novel may lie.
That's not to say that Mobius is without problems. The
writing is good, but it needs to be tighter (you can't twist something into a
mobius strip for instance). The plot twists and turns and their are almost too
many characters. At one point the writer muses, jokingly that in real life
people you meet can have frustratingly similar names. In a post-modern
"breaking of the fourth wall" the author gives some of her characters
similar names. But the reason authors don't emulate real life is it makes
book hard to follow and I felt drowned occasionally
in personalities.
Our heroine, Katherine, has fallen in with a bad lot. Well
bad in the sense that they are the sort of people who make vast amounts of
money in the city of London, or selling real-estate in Dalston to the types who
make money in the city of London. Her lover strains to prove himself to her
through a ritual display of nice wines, good meals, expensive cars and sound
systems. All lovingly if contemptuously described by the author. Katherine
rejects these trinkets. She's made of sterner stuff, though her affection for
her partner means that his disappearance encourages her to go on a search that
takes her from London, to Italy and back.
The disappearance appears to be caused by the same shady
group who organised a rather exotic sex-party. Katherine meets Nick at the
orgy, and together they witness an unusual, and unpleasant scene that makes
them question what's happening, in part because they both suffer from memory
loss.
I'm not going to dwell on the plot. Frankly if you've found
your interest pricked so far, you'll probably get this for your kindle anyway.
What I want to finish on is the sex. Or is it porn? There is a lot of sex in
this book. Quite a lot of it graphically described. Rarely have I read a novel
that mentions the perineum more than once. There are quite a lot of orgasms and
bodily fluids, ejaculation and scratching. That some of this crosses over into
violence will not surprise those who've read some of the less well written
books out there, particularly in an era when everyone seems to think vampires
are essential to literature. Many readers will find this distasteful, and I
wonder if others will be tempted to dismiss it as irony. Certainly it brought
to mind a couple of stories I'd read by Poppy Z Brite. On the other hand,
Abrams has some of the style of Iain Banks and with a good editor will no-doubt
improve.
I'm not a prude, nor am I particularly squeamish. But the
sexualised violence here, countered with an occasional critique of the society
that produces it, felt too disjointed from the main thrust of the novel. In
some ways, this is a classic coming of age novel. In others it is a horror
story. On the one hand you could dismiss this as a bit of dodgy porn, but on
the other hand Ann Abrams has written a first novel that is genuinely unusual.
Given the right marketing, and a good editor, Ann Abrams may
break out of the grey. Certainly if she’s pushed forward as the thinking person’s
alternative to Fifty Shades of Grey
she may make it. What the readers will actually think when they read it is an
entirely different question.
No comments:
Post a Comment