The book then is a study of how ancient cultures dealt with the fringes of their influence, and how the places and people of the periphery influenced wider Empires. For most ancient people,"the further away you were from the core of that society, the further away you were from civilisation itself". But the reality was that those people did not see themselves in that way, and their own place was the centre of their universe.
Owen Rees looks at a number of examples of this. Olbia in modern Ukraine was a Greek city on the Black Sea. This was, says Rees, the "outermost reach of the Greek world". Nonetheless the Greek world did reach there. But it was an outpost of Greece among the legendary and violent Scythian nomads who fought on horseback and who might turn themselves into wolves. The city itself "almost absorbed that muthical mustique, that sense of unknown truths, rumours and misunderstandings". But the city wasn't a tiny outpost. It was a thriving city, an economic powerhouse and the centre of trading for a whole region. The people of Olbia, trading salted fish,
which could be transported throughout the Greek world as a luxury item. But they also exported leather, salt, grain and enslaged people, possiblity supplied by the surrounding Scythian communities... Olbia imported wine, olive oil and fine pottery from further south... as far afield as Egypt.
The Greeks believed that the Scythian's rejected their culture but in reality Olbia represents the coming together of culture and the exchange of ideas, as well as trade goods. The Greek myths of Olbia were just that. The city was not a "carbon copy" of other Greek places, but had a "flair all of its own". The edges of Greek influence were ragged and merging elsewhere.
We see the same elsewhere, in multiple examples. The blending and merging of cultures and ideas at the fringes of ancient empires but ones were sometimes the blurring goes much further in to the heart of that culture. Perhaps the most unexpected, and fascinating example, is one from Bais, in Madhya Pradesh, northern India. Here a monument commerates the Greek ambassador who came there and met with Bhagavata, the son of Dion, from Taxila (in modern Pakistan). Rees explores this remarkable and unexpected event - an ancient Greek ambassador in India. Not just that, but one who appears to have gone native. It demonstrates, says Rees, that Taxila was:
a city filled with learning and cultural exchange, where religious innovation and novelty was embraced and given space to thrive. It was a place where no one language superseded another, but where different languages sat side by side.
This might, perhaps, not seem to controversial. But Rees is tackling a problem whereby we tend to see history through the prism of a few, local, examples. Ancient Greece and Rome are the societies by which others are judged, and allegedly form the bedrock for modern culture and politics. Instead, Rees points out, they are also assimilations of other cultures, influenced, shaped and changed by much wider and less well known civilisations. Rees says, "by focusing out minds on the narrow, traditional narratives of history we do not appreciate just how many stories, innovations and shared histories we inadvertantly eradicate".
I enjoyed Owen Rees' book, but at times I found his central argument was lost in overwhelming detail. At times I also felt it was obscured and needed drawing out more. But the central idea - that cultures are not monolithic and are shaped by interaction and exchange, is one that we could do well to remember today.
Related Reviews
Beard - Emperor of Rome
Al-Rashid - Between Two Rivers: Ancient Mesopotamia and the Birth of History
Balter - The Goddess & the Bull: Çatalhöyük An Archaeological Journey to the Dawn of Civilisation
No comments:
Post a Comment