The Siege of Malta by the Ottoman Empire was one of the most brutal battles of the era. The war was fought with the most modern of weapons. Over the three months perhaps 20,000 people lost their lives. Most of those were from the besieging forces. The Knights of Malta, who were completely outnumbered, fought an impressive defensive action, though as Bull emphasises, it was only because of the slimest of chances that they were succesful.
One of the important things about Bull's book is that he places the Siege in a much wider context. The Ottoman Empire had been gradually spreading its military and economic power through the Mediterranean. Inevitably it encountered other powers, most importantly those of Spain and the Italian states. But Bull is rightly wary of simply falling into the tired trap that this was a clash between "East and West". He notes that the Siege of Malta did not arise out of a simple desire to conquer on the part of the Ottomans, but rather the actions of the Knights of Malta themselves. Malta survived in large part because of sanctioned piracy that enabled the Knights, and others, to rob passing ships and steal food, wealth and slaves. This is not to say that the Ottoman's (and many other groups around the Mediterranean) did not also participate in piracy and slavery - quite the opposite. But rather to see that the "maritime activies of the Knights" drove the need to attack Malta, rather than simple expansion. As Bull repeatedly points out, Malta was at the extreme edge of the Ottoman naval forces' range. Their ability to hold Malta would have been near zero. This was an attempt to wipe out Knightly power for good.
The Ottoman Sultan's pronouncement cloaked his military ambition in religion (though pirate attacks on Muslim pilgrims were an huge problem for the Ottomans). The Sultan declared:
I intend to conquer the island of Malta and I have appointed Mustaga Pasha as commander of the campaign. The island of Mlata is a headquarters for infidels. The Maltese have already blocked the route utilised by Mulsim pilgrims and merchants in the East Medietrranean, on their way to Egypt.
The Knight's victory in the siege, due to a massive relief force was, in the end, remarkably swift. The Maltese victory over the besiegers became somewhat of a mythical victory that, as Bull relates, was told the length and breadth of Europe. It's story had the heroic arc of a great victory against the odds. But Bull, by contrast, argues it "was a momentous epic event that changed very little". From almost certain defeat, it was recast as a tremendously brave victory, and its leaders were turned into myths. Perhaps the great change was that in the afterglow of victory funds and resources poured into Malta, and the island was rebuilt and the new city of Valetta rebuilt.
Marcus Bull's account of the Siege is readable. But the structure of the book was a little confusing. Knowing nothing of events when I first picked it up, I was frustrated that there was no brief overview of context at the start. The Siege itself doesn't get mentioned until about page 100, and most of the opening of the book is context and the history of the Knights. There is nothing wrong with this, but the casual reader may be slightly befuddled. The final part of the book places Malta and the Medietrranean world in a wider global context. This is helpful. Too often events in the region are abstracted from the global picture. Bull places the actions of the Ottomans in the context of Spain and other European powers pushing their colonial agenda in the Americas. That said, I felt that at times this history was too abstracted from Malta itself.
On the whole though, this is a decent read for anyone wanting insights into Maltese history and the iconic 16th century Siege that has become somewhat of a founding myth for the island itself.
Related Reads
Holland - Fortress Malta: An island under siege 1940-1943
Cameron - Red Duster, White Ensign

No comments:
Post a Comment