Since its first publication in 2014 An Indigenous Peoples' History of the United States has become somewhat of a touchstone for histories of the Americas that seek to look at the history through the lens of settler colonialism. That said, this is not a dry academic text. It is a polemical work that seeks to link the ongoing settler colonial destruction of indigenous people with their resistance historically and today. The link to today is important. Dunbar-Ortiz makes it clear that the settler colonial origins of the United States, which are themselves rooted in the original and early settler project dating from European arrival in the Americas, continue to shape the US imperialist project today. As she says:
Why then does the popular US historical narrative of a "natural" westward movement persist? The answer is that those who still hold to the narrative remain captives of the ideology of 'manifest destonu,' according to which the United States expanded across the continent to assume its preordained size and shape. This ideology normalises the successive invasions and occupations of Indigenous nations and Mexico as not being colonialist or imperialist, rather simply ordained progress. In this view, Mexico was just another Indian nation to be crushed.
She continues that while the US invasion of Mexico is called the first foreign war by the US, it was not. "By 1846, the US had invaded, occupied and ethnically cleansed dozens of foreign nations east of the Mississippi".
One of the great strengths of the book is that Dunbar-Ortiz links the destruction of indigenous societies with wider, global questions, such as slavery and the development of global capitalism. Take the question of land. This is, she argues, central to the project of settler colonialism. But the structures of settler colonialism incorporate those at the bottom of society into the logic of land. Thus, writing about slavery, she says:
Every settler in the Southern states aspired to own land and slaves or to own more land and more lsaves, as both social status and wealth depended on the extent of property owned. Even small and landless farmers relied on slavery-based rule: the local slave planatation was the market for what small farmers produced, and planters hired landless settlers as overseers and sharecroppers.
Lincoln, as an opponent of slavery (though not genocide) had to offer "free land" to those that supported him and those that fought the South. But this free land was in the hands of indigenous nations. As such, "the dispersal of landless settler populations from east of the Mississippi served as an 'escape valve' lessening the liklihood of class conflict as the industrial revolution accelerated the use of cheap immigrant labour."
Resistance to the settler colonial project has shaped US policy. "Between the alternatives of extermination and termination (war policies) and preservation (peace policy) were interim periods chraacterised by benign neglect and assimilation." The delay in states like Montana getting recognition was because of native resistance. Opposition by indigenous people and their allies has helped protect and defend communities.
Why does this matter? Dunbar-Ortiz says that the structures built by settler colonialism remain today, both ideologically and in terms of politics and economics. The tactics learnt by the US military in exterminating Native Americans are still studied and used today. In some depressing quotes she shows how this even influenced how the US military and politicians thought about the enemy in the Middle East during the various Gulf Wars - reflecting policies and racism at the same time.
Even those whose ancestors were not part of the destruction of indigenous people come to be part of the structures because of the nature of the system itself. She writes:
In a settler society that has not come to terms with its past, whatever historical trauma was entailed in settling the land affects the assumptions and behaviour of living generations at any given time, including immigrants and the children of recent immigrants.
Restitution cannot come from compensation, though given the poverty of some many indigenous communities today, that would be helpful. It requires more thorough going change. Treaties need to be acknowledged. Sacred lands need to be returned, as do "stolen sacred items and body parts". But more importantly there needs to be a "radical reconfiguration" of the continent, "physically and psychologically". As Dunbar-Ortiz hints in her final lines, a quote from the poet Simon Ortiz, this will have to be revolutionary change.
The question of agency for that change matters though. Settler colonialism in some of its interpretations can lead to the idea that all descendents of Settlers are complicit in the ongoing destruction of indigenous communities. In this book Dunbar-Ortiz doesn't take up that issue explicitly. The question of land ownership or the aspiration to own property remains one way that the US system does try to buy off its population, and this land is always originally that stolen from the indigenous people. But it is also true that sections of the working class can be won to a strategy that sees indigenous people as allies, and is prepared to fight for their interests. These struggles (and perhaps the most obvious is the Standing Rock anti-pipeline protests) have demonstrated that it is possible to create unity against the Settler state. Those struggles together with wider anti-imperialist and anti-racist movements are what point towards a strategy for shattering the Settler Colonial structure that is the United States.
An Indigenous Peoples' History of the United States is perhaps one of the most impressive of the many books I've read on Native American history. Together with Nick Estes' book Our History is the Future I recommend it as required reading for those trying to understand the United States today. It is a remarkable book that I cannot recommend highly enough.
Related Reviews
Dunbar-Ortiz - Not A Nation of Immigrants: Settler colonialism, white supremacy & a history of erasure & exclusion
Englert - Settler Colonialism: An Introduction
Horne - The Dawning of the Apocalypse
Deloria Jr - Custer Died for your Sins: An Indian Manifesto
Fanon - The Wretched of the Earth
No comments:
Post a Comment